Saigoneer

BackHeritage » Saigon » Can Saigon Preserve its Historical Architecture?

Can Saigon Preserve its Historical Architecture?

The Ho Chi Minh City’s People’s Committee has launched a program aimed at preserving the city's architectural gems. Unfortunately, the focus is on the city's famous buildings rather than sites that are seriously threatened by unchecked development.

The program, with the intent to list and preserve Saigon’s artistic, iconic and collective architectural items, will rank sites based on the results of the Cultural Heritage Law, expected to be completed by the end of the year.

The list will be managed by the Geographic Information System (GIS), which is designed to capture, store, manipulate, analyze, manage and present different types of geographical data.

The program will also establish an agency which will identify and protect the city’s finest buildings and landscapes.

This is welcome news but it remains to be seen how far this program’s reach will extend. Other cities, such as New York, which places strong emphasis on preserving historical architecture, go to great lengths to do so. They place tight restrictions on not only changes to individual buildings, (singer, Nora Jones, spent years fighting her neighborhood preservation society to install new windows on her $4.9 million Brooklyn home) but entire neighborhoods.

Yes, the opera house is nice and the People’s Committee building has a majestic glow at night but these buildings are in no danger of being knocked down. The real danger to Saigon’s architectural history is its unregulated development and lack of zoning laws. This not only results in the loss of individual buildings but can change the face of an entire neighborhood.

Unlike cities such as New York, in Saigon, development overrides posterity. This is partially due to lack of regulations, but also class economics. It’s easy to tell a millionaire home owner to make costly repairs and upgrades to their Brooklyn brownstone but it’s unrealistic to expect the same from a middle-class shop house owner in District 5. This issue played out recently at Duong Lam ancient village where residents, unable to make costly repairs or expand their homes, have requested that the town’s heritage site title be removed.

We are huge proponents of preserving Saigon’s architectural soul but fear that this plan is too little too late. What's really needed is a preservation plan with a wider scope, one that doesn't concentrate on landmarks, but rather fine examples of architecture across the city. Zoning regulations would also go a long way in protecting the character of historical neighborhoods.

[Photo via OldSaigon]

Related Articles

in Saigon

10 Old Photos Of Carriages In Saigon

Before motorized transportation was the norm in Saigon, horse-drawn carts were used to move both goods and people.

in Saigon

10 Old Pictures (and History) of the Saigon Opera House

The Saigon Opera House (aka the Municipal Theatre) is one of Saigon’s oldest buildings and one of the city’s best examples of classical French architecture. Constructed at the turn of the 20th century...

in Saigon

10 Old Pictures of Advertisements in Saigon

Before 1975, large advertisements were commonplace in Saigon. But after the American War and the fall of capitalism in the South, ads were considered a vestige of the old order and were heavily regula...

in Saigon

10 Old Pictures of Art Deco Buildings in Saigon

Art deco is by far our favorite architectural style, one which luckily, Saigon has in spades. However, with each passing day, these buildings are being torn down to make way for modern structures whic...

in Saigon

10 Old Pictures of Cars in Saigon

Though cars have been present in the country since the turn of the 20th century, decades of war (1941 – 1975) and an economic stagnation (1975 – 1986) drastically reduced the number of automobiles in ...

in Saigon

10 Old Pictures of People in Saigon

We often look to old buildings in order reconnect with the past since they are clear and static reference points. Though useful, another important window into the past is the day-to-day lives of peopl...